What Prediabetes Actually Means (Fasting Glucose vs HbA1c)
"Prediabetes" is one of the most common things people over 50 get told after a blood test — and one of the least explained. Here's what fasting glucose and HbA1c actually measure, why the same sample gets a different verdict in the UK and the US, and the common condition that can make an HbA1c result wrong.
Prefer to watch? This guide is also an 11-minute video. Watch it on YouTube.
Right. Prediabetes.
It's one of the most common things a person over fifty gets told after a blood test, and it might be the least explained. You get a letter, or a text, and it says your blood sugar is raised. You're not diabetic. But you're not normal either. And that's usually where the explanation stops.
So you're left with a word that sounds like a diagnosis, a number you've never seen before, and no real sense of whether you should be worried or not.
Here's the thing that surprised me most when I went through the guidance. That exact same blood sample, sent to a lab in London and a lab in Chicago, can come back with two different answers. Not because one lab is wrong. Because they're using different cut-offs.
Today we're going through it properly. What fasting glucose measures. What HbA1c measures, and why it's the one your doctor probably cares about. What the word prediabetes actually means. And when HbA1c quietly gives you the wrong answer, which happens more often than you'd think.
Quick word about me. I'm a researcher, not a doctor. I read the studies and the lab guidance and I tell you what's in them. This is education, not medical advice, and nothing here should change any medication you're taking. That's between you and your doctor.
What it will do is make that letter make sense.
Two tests, two different questions
Before any numbers, the thing that makes all of this click.
There are two common blood sugar tests, and they're not two versions of the same measurement. They answer completely different questions.
Fasting glucose asks: what is your blood sugar right now, this morning, after not eating overnight?
HbA1c asks: what has your blood sugar been doing, on average, for the last few months?
One is a photograph. The other is a time-lapse.
And that's why you can have a perfectly respectable fasting glucose and a raised HbA1c at the same time. It's not a contradiction. The photograph was taken on a good morning. The time-lapse covers the other eighty-nine days.
So when something's flagged, the first useful question is which of the two it was. Because that tells you what's actually being described.
Fasting glucose
Fasting glucose first, because it's the simpler one.
You don't eat overnight, usually eight hours or so, and they measure the sugar in your blood in the morning. In the UK that's reported in millimoles per litre, and a typical normal result sits somewhere around four to five point four.
From about six point one up to six point nine, UK guidance calls that impaired fasting glucose. Seven point zero and above, on two separate occasions, is where diabetes gets diagnosed.
Now, the weakness of this test is right there in how it works. It's one morning. And blood sugar moves. It moves with illness, with a bad night's sleep, with stress, with steroid medication, with whatever the last few days looked like.
So a single fasting glucose slightly over the line is a reason to look again. It is not, on its own, a conclusion.
The question worth asking: was this a proper fast, and has it been repeated?
HbA1c, and why it won
Now HbA1c, which is the one most surgeries lean on these days, and the one whose name tells you nothing at all.
Here's what it's actually measuring. Sugar in your blood sticks to the haemoglobin inside your red blood cells. It's a slow, steady process, and once it's stuck, it stays stuck for the life of that cell. Red cells live about three to four months.
So if you measure how much of your haemoglobin is carrying sugar, you get an average of what your blood sugar has been doing across that whole period.
That's why it won. You don't have to fast. You can have it done at any time of day. And you can't tidy it up by eating carefully for two days beforehand, which, let's be honest, is what a lot of people do before a fasting test.
In the UK it's reported in millimoles per mole. Below forty-two is considered normal. Forty-eight and above, and that's diabetes.
Which leaves the gap in the middle. And that gap is the whole subject of this guide.
Ask your doctorWas this HbA1c or a fasting glucose? Because they mean different things.
The part nobody explains
Right. This is the bit I genuinely didn't know before I read the guidance, and it's the reason the internet is so confusing on this subject.
There is no single international definition of prediabetes.
In the UK, following NICE and World Health Organisation thresholds, non-diabetic hyperglycaemia is an HbA1c of forty-two to forty-seven millimoles per mole.
In the United States, the American Diabetes Association starts prediabetes at thirty-nine.
Same blood. Same sugar stuck to the same haemoglobin. A result of forty is completely normal in Britain and prediabetic in America.
It's the same story with fasting glucose. UK guidance starts the range at six point one. The ADA starts it at five point six.
Neither is a mistake. They're different judgements about where to draw a line on what is genuinely a smooth, continuous slope. There's no biological cliff edge at any of these numbers. Risk climbs gradually, and somebody has to pick a point to start paying attention.
Which is worth knowing for one very practical reason. If you've typed your number into a search engine and come back frightened, there's a decent chance you were reading American thresholds against a British result.
So what does prediabetes actually mean?
So if the line is arbitrary, what does landing in that range actually tell you?
It tells you you're on a slope. That's it. It is not a disease, and it's not a mild version of diabetes. It's a description of risk.
And the part that rarely gets said out loud: being in that range does not mean you're on a conveyor belt. A substantial proportion of people in the prediabetes range don't go on to develop type two diabetes. Some drift back into the normal range on their own.
That's not me telling you to relax. It's the opposite of a crisis and the opposite of nothing. It's a signal, arriving early, at the point where it's most useful.
What I'm not going to do is tell you what to eat or what to take. That's genuinely not my job, and it depends on things about you I can't see from here.
What I'd ask is this: given my result, my age, and everything else about me, what's my actual risk, and what would you suggest?
When HbA1c is wrong
Now the caveat, and it connects straight back to the full blood count guide.
HbA1c works by measuring sugar stuck to your red blood cells. So it quietly assumes your red blood cells are behaving normally. When they aren't, the number stops meaning what it's supposed to mean.
If your red cells are being destroyed early, or you've had a recent transfusion, there's less time for sugar to accumulate. The result comes back lower than the truth.
And here's the one that catches people. Untreated iron deficiency can push HbA1c up. Not because your blood sugar rose. Because iron-starved red cells hang around longer than they should, collecting sugar for longer.
So somebody with undiagnosed iron deficiency can be told they're prediabetic on the strength of a number their blood sugar didn't cause.
NICE guidance is explicit about this. HbA1c shouldn't be used to diagnose diabetes in people with haemoglobin disorders like sickle cell or thalassaemia, in active haemolysis, after a recent transfusion, or with untreated iron, B12 or folate deficiency. In those situations you use fasting glucose or a glucose tolerance test instead.
Which is a very good reason to look at your full blood count and your HbA1c on the same page, rather than one at a time.
Ask your doctorIs there anything about my blood count that would make my HbA1c unreliable?
What should you ask your doctor?
So, three questions. These work whether your result was flagged or not.
One. Which test was this, and what was the actual number? Not "it was fine" or "it was a bit up". The number and the units. You want it, because next year's number only means something next to this year's.
Two. Is there anything in my blood count that could be affecting this result? That's the iron question, and it takes your doctor about ten seconds to check.
Three. If I'm in the raised range, what's my risk over the next few years, and what would you actually recommend for me? Not general advice. For you.
None of those are confrontational. They're the questions that turn a text message into information.
The habit, again
Same habit as every one of these guides, and blood sugar is where it pays off most obviously.
One HbA1c is a data point. Five of them, taken a year apart, is a direction. And the direction is the thing that actually matters.
A result of forty-four that's been forty-four for six years is a very different situation from a forty-four that was thirty-eight three years ago. Identical number. Completely different story.
Your surgery has those old results. They're sitting in your record. Most people have never asked to see them.
So the question, one more time. What's my trend?
The short version
Right. To pull it together.
Fasting glucose is one morning. HbA1c is three months, and it's the one that's harder to game. Prediabetes is a line drawn on a smooth slope, and it's drawn in a different place depending on which country's guidance you're reading. Being in that range is a signal, not a sentence. And if your iron is low, that number may not be telling you the truth at all.
None of which tells you what to do next. That depends on you, and it's a conversation worth having properly.
Sources and further reading
- NICE CKS: Diabetes: diagnosis and HbA1c thresholds
- WHO: Use of glycated haemoglobin (HbA1c) in the diagnosis of diabetes mellitus
- NHS: Type 2 diabetes
- Lab Tests Online UK: HbA1c
- American Diabetes Association: Standards of Care, diagnosis criteria
I'm a researcher, not a doctor. Health Unfiltered is education, not medical advice. Nothing here should be used to start, stop or change any medication or supplement. That is a decision for you and a qualified clinician. If a result worries you, speak to your doctor.
The other guides
- How to read a blood test report
- Mistakes before a blood test
- Full blood count
- Cholesterol and the lipid panel
- Blood pressure
- Kidney function, eGFR and creatinine
- Thyroid, TSH and free T4
- Iron and ferritin
- Liver enzymes
- CRP and inflammation
- Urea and electrolytes (U&E)
Want every marker in one place? The Over-50 Blood Test Decoder covers each line of a routine panel in plain English, with the question to ask for each one.